HUD Targets Section 8 Fraud: Citizenship Status Required for All Tenants

This story was almost completely ignored by corporate media. VIN News ran it late last week, headlined, “HUD Cracks Down on Illegal Immigrants in Public Housing, Orders Proof of Citizenship for Section 8 Tenants.” More pressure for voluntary self-deportation! You don’t have to go home, but you can’t stay HERE.

The big media platforms have always covered Trump’s HUD moves before. And this is a huge HUD story. So their sudden silence is perhaps the biggest story of all.

Section 8 is a taxpayer-funded housing charity, where the government euphemistically provides “vouchers” —rent checks— to low-income tenants, who give the checks to landlords, who cash them at the Bank of Uncle Sam.

Section 8 isn’t just a housing subsidy— it’s a shadow industry. Billions in taxpayer dollars surge each year through housing authorities into private hands, underwriting rent for millions of families and spawning a whole ecosystem: developers who build bespoke apartment complexes tailor-made for guaranteed government rent; Wall Street banks and investors (e.g., Wells Fargo, BlackRock, Bank of America) who scoop up tax credits and steady returns; NGOs that shepherd applicants through the waiting lists; and professional managers paid by Washington to keep the sewer pipes flowing.

For big investors, Section 8 is steadier than the stock market. Government checks never bounce, and lenders get insanely valuable tax credits. For tenants, it fosters dependency and inflated rents. And for the bureaucrats, it’s a permanent feeding ground.

Section 8 is less a welfare program than a for-profit coral reef, where schools of federal dollars, activist groupers, Wall Street sharks, bureaucratic clownfish, and minnow-like immigrants all jostle for survival in an interdependent financial ecosystem. Nudge the reef, and the whole ecosystem shudders.

🔥 This year, Trump officials started citing cases of abuse, like people who’ve lived in Section 8 their entire lives, from birth through retirement. Officials like HUD Secretary Scott Turner started saying revolutionary things like “Section 8 was meant to be a trampoline, not a hammock.” Or like ensuring that HUD housing is only for American citizens, or removing foreign language translations from HUD’s website.

Then, in its newest directive last week, HUD just dropped a giant steel anchor right onto the Section 8 reef, ordering every housing authority in America to surface a full census of its tenants— names, addresses, rents, and, most explosively, citizenship status:

Within 30 days of receipt of this notice, HUD is requesting that every Public Housing Authority (PHA) provide a full and comprehensive accounting of all tenants who are receiving a Section 8 voucher and or residing in HUD-funded housing. HUD is requiring the name, mailing address, number of bedrooms, the cost of the unit and proof of American citizenship or eligible immigration status.

It might look like a paperwork shuffle, a bureaucratic nest of new forms and attestations. But it’s really a sonar ping across the whole housing ecosystem, sending ripples of panic through immigrant households, jolting landlords who’d rather not ask questions, and stirring advocacy groups who see tentacles of immigration enforcement snaking between every line of the form.

And illegal immigrants see the dark shadow of an enforcement whale drifting right over the reef.

In other words, if tenants reveal their “undocumented” status and current address, they risk getting promptly deported. If the owners and operators fail to comply, they risk their sure-thing rent checks and tax credits— a risk they will not take. That’s what’s so quietly brilliant about this move.

HUD just wants the data, which under the law must be provided upon request. It isn’t threatening to evict or deport anybody. So there’s nothing tangible to sue over. The threat of immigration enforcement is the unstated hammer, but nobody’s actually swinging it. And once HUD gets the data about the numbers of non-Americans enjoying taxpayer-funded Section 8 housing —one can fairly ask why it’s never been collected before— it will be a political Patriot Missile.

For a list of public housing in Jacksonville, check out this link here.

Jeff Childers

Jeff Childers is the president and founder of the Childers Law firm. Jeff interned at the Federal Bankruptcy Court in Orlando, where he helped write several widely-cited opinions. He then worked as an associate with the prestigious firm of Winderweedle, Haines, Ward & Woodman in Orlando and Winter Park, Florida before moving back to Gainesville and founding Childers Law. Jeff served for three years on the Board of Directors of the Central Florida Bankruptcy Law Association. He has also served on the Board of Directors of the Eighth Judicial Bar Association, and on the Rules Committee for the Northern District of Florida Bankruptcy Court. Jeff has published several articles as co-author with Professor William Page of the Levin College of Law (University of Florida) on the topic of anti-trust in the Microsoft case. He also is the author of an article on the topic of Product Liability in the Software Context. Jeff focuses his area of practice on commercial litigation, elections law, and constitutional issues. He is a skilled trial litigator and appellate advocate. http://www.coffeeandcovid.com/

Comments

Post Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *